As we walk the Jesus way every day, it is easy to take the path often traveled. What seems to be a smooth and level way is actually a way full of danger. The path often traveled is called moralism. It is the way of the Pharisee in our Savior’s parable in Luke chapter 18.
The Pharisee is better than you. You don’t have to ask him because he will tell you he is better than you. He prays God, I thank you that I am not like other men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week; I give tithes of all that I get. You might call the Pharisee’s behavior “virtue signaling”. The Cambridge Dictionary says virtue signaling is “an attempt to show other people that you are a good person, for example by expressing opinions that will be acceptable to them, especially on social media”. You don’t have to be on social media to see virtue signaling. Take a trip to the isthmus in Madison and see for yourself what some call virtue signaling. Count the signs in people’s yards telling you who or what they support or don’t support. Note how some refuse to mow their yard in order to spare pollinating insects. See the many flags they fly from their porch. Look at what car they drive, or don’t drive as the case may be.
Politically and socially astute Madison residents aren’t the only virtue signalers. When you put a bumper sticker or a decal on your vehicle, you’re declaring something about your goodness. Even if you allow a sign promoting a particular politician in your yard, it’s a virtue signal. From the brand of clothing you wear to the products you put in your hair, you are trying to show how good you are to others. You cannot escape virtue signaling.
Some virtue signaling is more benign than others. You can’t help the fact that a particular name brand has a logo that appears on your clothing. You can, however, help your behavior around other people. Another neologism of recent times is “humblebrag” You’re bragging on yourself, but you’re doing it in such a way that doesn’t call attention to the fact that you’re bragging on yourself. You’ve seen that behavior from people before. You’ve probably caught yourself doing it, too. You cannot escape the humblebrag.
The Old Adam loves a self back-pat. He loves to tell others how good he is, and how bad you are. The Pharisee’s prayer is an egregious example of humblebragging and virtue signaling. If I tell you I am better than you, then you’ll change your ways and be more like me. By the time you start acting more like me, I will have moved the goalposts and become more virtuous than you again. So you’ll have to do as I do, but I will have progressed again to a higher level of virtue than you. It’s a vicious cycle. The only end is absolute perfection, something that cannot be achieved this side of Paradise. But don’t tell the humblebragger that lest he or she find another way to signal their virtue and sweep you under the rug.
The Pharisee’s prayer shows he believes in another god who isn’t the one true God. That false god’s name is I. Five times he mentions the first person singular pronoun I. Like the best actor, he wants others to look at him. Do as he says and as he does and you, too, will shut the kingdom of heaven in people’s faces. They will deserve it because you are better than they are. You are more pious. You don’t extort. You don’t rob. You aren’t unjust. You don’t commit adultery, at least out in the open, and you certainly aren’t a tax collector.
You are all these things the Pharisee says he isn’t and more. You, like him, bow the knee to the god of self and hope that others will see how much better you are than them. You have to protect them from themselves in the name of being caring and fair. You don’t need a Savior. You don’t need salvation. You don’t need any sin offering applied to you.
Yet you do. You need all these things because you, like the Pharisee, are not righteous. All the piety, pomp, and pride you put on display means nothing before the living God. The prophet Hosea proclaims I desire mercy and not sacrifice, the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings. What you desire is what the tax collector prays for: mercy.
The thrust of the word mercy in the tax collector’s prayer is for God to apply His sin offering to you. That is why Jesus says about the tax collector, this man went down to his house justified, rather than the other. For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but the one who humbles himself will be exalted. Humility is receptiveness to the sin offering God makes for your sake.
The tax collector is one of the most despised people among the Jews. Tax collectors in the Roman Empire tended to overcharge people in order to take a cut for themselves. Even today we don’t think much of the IRS. Imagine if every IRS agent was in business for themselves, gathering not only what the government wants but quite a bit more that ended up in the agent’s pocket that Uncle Sam doesn’t need to know about. The thief, the cheater, the liar, the tax collector, beats his breast and prays God, be merciful to me, a sinner!
The humblebragger is brought low and the one despised the most by society is raised up. But that’s the way it is as we walk the Jesus way, isn’t it? Again, humility is receptiveness to the sin offering God makes for your sake. Being here in the Lord’s house to rest in His presence in Word and Sacrament is a counter-cultural act of humility. You don’t have to hang signs, quit mowing your lawn, or pontificate on social media to express your morality. You sit in a pew, stand up for a time, and even kneel down at the rail to receive what you desire the most: forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation in hearing the Word, eating the Word, and drinking the Word. All these actions say Heavenly Father, apply Your sin offering, Jesus Christ, to me.
As you leave His house fortified with forgiveness of sins, you go down to your house justified, declared righteous before the Father’s face. As you walk the Jesus way every day, that declaration of righteousness colors everything you think, do, and say. That’s not moralism for the sake of moralism. That’s being who are are where God puts you. No more humblebragging. No more virtue signaling. No more moralism. Only living in Jesus and loving others as Jesus first loved you. That’s humility. That’s the way of the tax collector, the Jesus way. God, be merciful to me, apply Your sin offering, Jesus Christ, to me, a sinner!